Many pet owners struggle with the decision of desexing and whether or not to breed their dog. It’s one of the most important decisions you’ll make regarding your pet, so it’s worth doing some research. As with anything, there are both pros and cons of desexing.
The pros
1. Preventing unwanted litters
Australia has an over-supply of puppies and each year, thousands of puppies are euthanised both here and around the world. Every puppy born requires a good home and, considering one female dog and its offspring can produce approximately 20,000 puppies in the space of five years, that’s a lot of puppies to find homes for! Desexing stops a dog from accidentally breeding, so if you don’t plan on finding quality homes for any future puppies or kittens, desexing your pet will save any unwanted litters.
2. Curbs aggression and dominance issues
Desexing male dogs early enough will reduce the chance of the dog developing aggression problems, without affecting his personality. Most vets recommend getting male dogs desexed by six months of age if you’re not planning on breeding. Desexing should be considered the prevention of aggression, rather than the cure. Without it, dogs can display aggression to other dogs and people, and be very dominant and possessive of toys and food.
Desexing a female dog can reduce the risk of sudden “PMS-like” symptoms brought on as she goes on “heat”. In between heats, she is in a time of reproductive inactivity and is not receptive to males. Her blood flow to the reproductive organs and hormone levels are at their lowest and all is calm. On heat, however, massive surges of hormones are released and this can affect your dog’s temperament. Your normally docile friend can suddenly get very moody.
Cats are not exempt either, with many cats becoming aggressive when on heat as well.
3. Protects your pet and others
In the early stages of being on heat, a bitch will bleed from her vulva and be very attractive to male dogs (not to mention messy in the home). Dogs can detect a female on heat from several kilometres away and will soon be lining up at your door. If your female isn’t that keen on the dog either, a scuffle can occur.
As ‘whole’ dogs can be aggressive, they are much more likely to run into trouble with other dogs. All it takes is them to pick the wrong fight to get seriously hurt.
4. Reduces the risk of roaming
Male dogs and cats are much more likely to roam in search of a mate which increases the risk of them getting lost, taken, run over or involved in a fight. Reduced roaming also limits contact with infectious diseases, including Feline AIDS.
5. Limits loud mewing
Cats have a breeding season that lasts from about July to March (but sometimes longer) and will come into season or “heat” once every three weeks. During this time, cats cry and howl frequently and can act strangely. Cats on heat will also get aggressive and the noise of cats fighting (or mating) at night can be disturbing for anyone trying to sleep.
6. Prevents illness
There are a number of common illnesses that can be prevented by desexing. These include:
- Uterine cysts and pyometra in female cats and dogs.
- Prostate problems and tumours around the anus in male dogs.
- Hormonal disturbances.
- Cancer in the mammary glands.
- Mastitis in the mammary glands.
- Tumours and cysts of the ovaries and testicles.
7. Limits spraying and marking
Tomcats love to spray urine all over the walls in your house and dogs will cock their leg at everything in sight when not desexed. This is part of their procedure for marking their territory and can create some rather awful smells.
8. They won’t necessarily become overweight
Many people fear that their dog will get “fat and lazy” when desexed, but this can easily be explained and prevented. Your pet’s metabolism changes following the procedure and less food is required to maintain the same body weight. Desexing itself doesn’t cause obesity, it’s the quantity and quality of food you give your pet that causes it. If you reduce your pet’s food intake to counter for the fact they make more efficient use of food, instead of diverting food into making hormones, there’s no reason why your pet should put on weight.
9. Your pet insurance premium will be lower
Petsecure believes that de-sexing plays a role in responsible pet ownership and, to support families who take this action, our premiums take account of whether or not a pet has been de-sexed.
The cons
1. No breeding
There are no real disadvantages to desexing your cat or your dog, other than that they won’t be able to produce offspring. Even then, this is only a disadvantage if you are unsure whether or not to breed. If you don’t plan on breeding your pet, desexing is a much kinder thing to do than keeping your pet isolated when on heat.
2. Rare cases of hyperthyroidism
In rare cases, lethargy and weight gain can be the result of hypothyroidism, which can stem from desexing. Hypothyroidism can also lead to skin infections and hair loss.
3. Increased risk of the following conditions
- Increased risk of urinary incontinence, when leaking of urine occurs while relaxed or sleeping.
- Increased risk of hip dysplasia and cruciate ligament disease.
- Increased risk of cognitive disorder in old age, essentially “doggie dementia”.
- Possible increased risk of neoplasias.
Desexing your pet
Generally speaking, there is little or no reason to keep your pet able to procreate if you don’t plan on breeding them. The benefits of desexing far outweigh the minimal cons, and many animal lovers feel that desexing is the more humane option if you don’t plan to allow your pet to breed. False and unwanted pregnancies are never good, and desexing puts a stop to this as well as helping to keep your pet safe.
Still not convinced? Consider this: desexed pets are cheaper to register with the council and will be less likely to escape in search of a mate!
I knew that desexing your dog prevents them from having puppies (and I agree that the rate of unwanted puppies is insane right now) but I didn’t know that it actually reduced the risk of roaming. My dog is a very independent dog that keeps trying to wander off, and while I was considering having him desexed for the puppies reason, it would be great if it helped keep my dog at home. My neighbor has a rather aggressive dog; I wonder if she needs to get hers desexed as well?
Hi Rhianna, yes, it could help with the wandering! I am sure your vet can also give you good advice if you are uncertain.
Funny that this seems biased, and starts adding in Cats for pros pushing desexing
It’s recently been practise to advise people that desexing can lead to cancers, where as before it was thought to be “as above”.
The recommendation for desexing age is now 18 months as earlier desexing will stunt a dogs growth as well
I will now include links, I would like to see links for the above information otherwise it is simply opinion
Lastly, if you have a dog (because we are not talking about cats) it’s a parenting desision to let your dog roam, if you are careful and check fences and gates are secure, it really shouldn’t happen often enough for 20,000 puppies in 5 years (again links please) to be created.
Opinion, logic or fact?
Recent study
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4096726/
Previous reports with research from 1990’s to <2007
https://www.rspca.org.au/sites/default/files/website/Campaigns/responsible-pet-ownership/Early%20Age%20Desexing%20Research%20Report%202010.pdf
Hi Mark, thank you for your feedback. It is not the intention to be biased, and that is not the reason to add cats to the information. It is true that there are many views about de-sexing, and when would be the best time to do it. I am not sure what you mean when you say it’s a parenting decision to allow your pets to roam. If it is on your property, then yes, but definitely not outside of your property. That would dangerous for the pet, and illegal as well at least in Australia. Our advice would be to talk to your vet if in doubt about the pros and cons of desexing, and the timing. I think that we can all agree there are far too many pets in shelters who end up being euthanised, and de-sexing is part of the solution. Liz
Thanks Mark.
I tend to agree.
As an owner of a non aggressive, non territory marking, non roaming dog I see no need for me to spend the hundreds of dollars that the vet keeps insisting I do because “it’s best for the dog”.
I have a very placid labrador and he is 12mths old. He is a little timid. I feel I would be better off not getting him dexexed based on less likely to get negative health benefits and to not undermine his confidence.
Mark the 2nd link you provided, concerning early age desexing, seems to support arguments for desexing rather than not and undermines your position rather than supporting it. Not sure if that was your intention.
Good on you, Mark & Danny. Liz Walden’s is a highly biased, not to say thoughtless article. It grossly favours desexing and offers only weak unproven evidence of the ‘advantages’. We should view animal desexing much as we do human. What civilised person nowadays promotes the routine castration of humans? The Nazis ruthlessly favoured desexing to rid the world of ‘undesirables’. Today, vets always encourage desexing our pets because it is an easy regular source of income for them (much as the sadistic inhuman practice of circumcision is to doctors). If your dog is not unduly aggressive and not inclined to wander, leave the poor fellow be. Allow him a full healthy life – like my amiable cheerful little chap – who is always a joy in his entirety.
Hi Joe, I can assure you it is not the intention to be biased, and I have nothing to gain from this. There are many views about de-sexing, but I don’t agree that vets promote de-sexing to make money. It’s more likely that they prefer to prevent the consequences. Our advice would be to take advice from your vet. Of course, you are free to make your own decision for your little chap – who sounds like a wonderful dog, but sadly not all dogs are like yours!
My family used to breed dogs. So growing up I never had a dog male or female that was desexed. Our dogs were all healthy,obedient and did not ever wander off ortry to escape.. They did smetimes fight with other dogs of the same sex but never dogs of opposite sex and never to the extent of injury..more there was just a winner which was just the other dog giving up and running away. Years later as an adult I got a male dog that was 19months old not desexed. At vets advice i desexed him due to being told the “pros” in this article. It did not stop him misbehaving…only consistent training and time stopped that (1year later) however, unlike my previous entire dogs…my desexed dog was often attacked and injured by other desexed dogs of both sexes. He then died at 6years old of cancer. That was the shortest lifespan and was in the most dogfights of any entire dog i had ever owned. Hence i now have a new dog …entire male and i have no intention of desexing him and so far i have no problems with his behaviour in anyway (no escaping no aggression, no humping, no running away, no fighting other dogs…and he is a husky. (Breed is renoun for escaping and running away even when desexed ? !! So frankly i believe desexing has npthing to do with behaviour. It comes down to your dogs own personality and how you raise and train them. As for their health it is ridculos to think that interfering with hormones /reproductive systems etc especially in young dogs nowhere near fully matured, is not going to damage them. If i cut your leg off when you were 7 months old your body will learn to accomodate the loss…but you would never be able to walk run or swim as you could have if left with all your limbs intact…it is as simple as that.
Thank you for sharing your experience Sue.
I agree too. Having a very placid labrador I can not see why I should get him desexed with all the negative health benefits it brings. Along with affecting his confidence. He is already quite cautious.
Hi Liz, I’d love your feedback please. My dog is from a shelter and was desexed at 8 weeks old. He is the most placid dog and has a great temperament until he comes into contact with a dog that’s intact. He will run and start menacing him. I correct his behaviour and think it’s all good but he can’t help himself. I think have to resort to putting him back on lead. Any suggestions please? He is 4 years old now.
Hi Amanda, sorry but I am not in a position to give advice on this matter. I suggest you discuss with your vet. Thanks Liz
I feel I have not picked the right option our Maltese shitzu of 3 years old was desexed last Friday and she has changed sooooo much.
She now wimpers/cries all the time she is not her cheeky gorgeous self anymore .
She carries around a toy all the time this is a new thing
Will not eat .
I feel so sad what happened to my Daisy
Hi Sharee, it is still very early days and is quite possible your dog is in pain. I really think you need to consult the vet who did the procedure (as soon as possible) about this to see if pain relief would be helpful for her.
Geeze while cats are mostly out doing what ever they please no restraint no commands to keep them in check. Our dogs are leashed, and trained and fenced in to their property. It’s up to the owner of mans best friend to raise that being with love and kindness and give it a safe home to stop it from leaving the property. Dogs don’t deserve such a flawed species to call its owner. It’s our fault that these things can happen due to neglect and careless attitude. So we take a short cut and take away something that is not our right to take. If you can’t be there for your dog and create an environment that best suited for them 100% then fish is the pet for you
I want to thank all the contributors in this article. I had my suspicions that desexing my awesome Kelpie/cattle (boy) was the wrong thing to do. He’s been trained since I got him, has a beautiful personality, gets plenty of exercise daily (over 7km), has a beautiful dog friendly (though smallish) backyard, gets plenty of affection and cuddles from me, socialises beautifully at dog parks, and given all these factors, I couldn’t understand my vet’s advice. I was warned of aggression and given all the other reasons provided in this promo for desexing. Unfortunately, this article is clearly biased, regardless of Liz’s denials, and is the same advice given by vet’s. Perhaps there are exceptions to the rule, but at this stage I see no reason to remove a hormone producing part of my dog that Mother Nature provided to keep his body and mind working in synergy. I also agree with those that suggest good ownership is a more effective tool than expensive and arguably inhumane surgical procedures. Thanks again to the brave people who stand up for what’s right. It’s appreciated.
Thank you for sharing your experience, and your feedback
Hello, I have a male pug that will be 6 in May, he is not aggressive but he is very territorial and urinates on everything including his food bowl and bed. When he comes inside it is not long before he urinates inside as well. I would like to get another dog soon but I did not want him teaching the new pup bad habits or being aggressive towards it, asside from the obvious health benefits would getting him desexed help fix any bad habits or do you think he would be too far gone at his age to have any real affect on his personality or habits? I look forward to hearing your response, thanks
I’m interested to know if getting a older dog desexed will cause health problems in the future e.g greater chance of cancer (from what i’ve read) . I was looking to adopt a 3 year old female (pug x) who would need to be desexed.
I suggest you discuss this with your vet.
I have two dogs (A doberman and a german shepherd) We got the German Shepherd when the Doberman was 1 and a half and they have been best friends ever since, until recently… Our german shepherd is now nearly a year and a half old and has randomly started attacking our doberman out of no where. We don’t know the reason, it wasn’t over food or anything like that. It’s the third time it has happened and it happened so bad the other day he wanted to kill the doberman. We have had to take him away for a few days and we are getting him desexed. Do you think this will help? Or is it too far gone?
I forgot to mention the doberman was desexed 6 months ago.